drawn to the art style and color usage in How to
Understand Israel in 60 Days or Less, which
prompted our decision to read it. Little did we know
that thenarration would contain heavier topics than we
had envisioned with the watercolors and thin outlines.
One question that kept popping into our minds was,
“How does Glidden’s view of Israel develop throughout
the novel? ”From the beginning, it is made clear her
decision to go on the birthright trip is to reassure her view
of Israel as the “bad guy” in the Israel-Palestine conflict.
When Glidden first attends the birthright trip, she already
decides that Israel is wrong, taking a progressive leftist
view point. Her skeptical attitude causes her to hold a
negative opinion about the trip, assuming it to be infused
with “zionist propaganda”. Because of her determination,
we often found ourselvesfrustrated at her lack of empathy
and closed mindset. This particular page of the comic is a
scene where the tour guide and Sarah are talking, and she
brings up why Israel has to be a Jewish state. Hurt, the tour
guide retorts back to make her understand his side. On page
119, Glidden says, “It’s just more complicated than you
think."
Her cynical view point comes off as hypocritical as she
attempts to disregard the viewpoints of Israelis living
through this conflict,assuming they have been
brainwashed, while her limited knowledge is through
the internet instead of first person experience.
pg. 119 |
always makes an effort to nitpick others’words.
Glidden criticizes how the Israelis are handling the
Palestinian conflict, believing they are overbearing,
yet assumes what she thinks to be right before
taking a step into the country. She frequently
reminds the reader her goal is to reassure her previous
assumptions about Israel as the bad guys too. On page 104, “
I came here… I think I wanted to know for sure that Israel
was the bad guy. I wanted to know that I could cut it out of
my life for good.”
pg. 104 |
desensitized; however, the speech delivered in
Independence Hall makes her change a little. She
becomes vulnerable to thereal pressing issues, recognizing
it is more than just politics. Her empathy takes over and
sends her into episodes of emotional breakdowns. As
she continues to learn more and be receptive to others’
perspectives, she finds herself caught in a limbo. There
is no definite right or wrong, and it deeply bothers her
as it was her mission to prove to herself Israel is the bad
guy. Glidden begins to acknowledge that the solution is not
clean cut, and everyone has different opinions. Ultimately,
everything is more complicated than she thought.
Pg. 106 |
prejudice against Israel. She slowly recognizes that many of
the actions of Israelis were due to their need to survive, and
even acknowledges the difficulty the early Jews of Israel
faced after the presentation in the Independence Hall.
pg. 96 |
She also reaches out to her fellow travelers asking for
their viewpoints. Rather than declaring Israelis make
immoral choices and brainwashtheir people, Glidden asks
more questions while vocalizing her internal emotional
battle. Her struggle tograsp a clearcut view on Israel is
heightened through these conversations with her peers
after the Independence Hall speech.
We think it’s left to the reader to interpret her feelings at
the end of the novel because it isn’t explicitly stated, but
it is clear that something has changed. Her
closed-mindedness gradually changes into an
understanding and sympathetic nature. And so, her
original plan to turn her back on Israel didn't work out in
the end.Instead, she finds her second home and grows a
little closer to it. If you are interested in learning more
about her journey, be sure to visit Glidden's website.
1 comment:
Your response to Glidden makes clear what attracted you to her comic and where you encountered issues with it (or with her, at least as a character). Given the prominence of the Independence Hall speech in Glidden's comic and in your post, provide the reader with a little more background on this speech and its place in the narrative.
Post a Comment